Eyebrow highlighters are the secret weapon for achieving that polished, defined brow look. Whether you want to lift your brow arch or add a subtle glow to your face, the right highlighter can enhance your features and pull your makeup look together. But with so many options on the market, how do you know which product will give you the best results?
In this guide, we’ve selected six top-rated eyebrow highlighters that deliver stunning effects, from subtle radiance to bold definition.
Top Recommendations
- Best Overall: Benefit High Brow Pencil
- Best for Natural Look: Anastasia Beverly Hills Highlighting Duo Pencil
- Best for Long-Lasting Wear: NYX Professional Makeup Wonder Pencil
Now, let’s take a closer look at the top-rated eyebrow highlighters and find out what makes each of them special.
1. Benefit High Brow Pencil
Benefit High Brow Pencil is a cult-favorite among makeup enthusiasts. It’s a creamy, matte highlighter designed to give your brows an instant lift. The soft pink-toned formula enhances the brow bone, creating a brighter and more youthful look.
The pencil glides smoothly over the skin and blends easily for a natural finish. Whether you’re going for a soft daytime look or a more defined evening style, this pencil is versatile enough to fit any occasion.
Pros:
- Creamy, easy-to-blend formula.
- Instantly lifts and brightens the brow area.
- Long-lasting and suitable for all skin tones.
Cons:
- Limited shade range.
- May require a sharpener for precise application.
The Benefit High Brow Pencil is the ultimate go-to for anyone looking to achieve a quick and easy brow lift. Its smooth application and subtle highlight make it a staple in any makeup routine.
2. Anastasia Beverly Hills Highlighting Duo Pencil
Anastasia Beverly Hills Highlighting Duo Pencil offers two finishes in one product—matte and shimmer. The matte side is perfect for adding a soft lift to the brow bone, while the shimmer side delivers a radiant glow for those special occasions.
This dual-ended pencil is highly pigmented and blends seamlessly for a flawless finish. It’s perfect for both subtle daytime looks and bold evening glam.
Pros:
- Dual-ended with matte and shimmer options.
- Highly pigmented and long-lasting.
- Easy to blend for a natural or bold finish.
Cons:
- Can be too creamy for oily skin.
- Slightly more expensive than other highlighters.
Anastasia Beverly Hills Highlighting Duo Pencil is ideal for makeup lovers who want the flexibility to switch between a natural matte look and a more radiant shimmer. Its versatile formula allows you to create different looks with ease.
3. NYX Professional Makeup Wonder Pencil
NYX Professional Makeup Wonder Pencil is a multi-purpose pencil that can be used as an eyebrow highlighter, eyeliner, and concealer. It’s perfect for defining your brows with a natural highlight while also concealing imperfections. The pencil is smooth and creamy, making it easy to apply precisely where you need it. With its long-lasting formula, you can enjoy a polished brow look that stays put throughout the day.
Pros:
- Multi-functional as a highlighter, concealer, and eyeliner.
- Creamy, long-lasting formula.
- Available in various shades to suit different skin tones.
Cons:
- May require frequent sharpening.
- Can be too subtle for a more dramatic highlight.
NYX Wonder Pencil is a versatile choice for those who want an all-in-one product. Its creamy texture and multi-use functionality make it a great addition to any makeup bag.
4. L’Oréal Paris Brow Stylist Brow Highlighter
L’Oréal Paris Brow Stylist Brow Highlighter is an affordable option that delivers great results. The highlighter has a unique brush tip applicator that makes it easy to apply the product precisely along the brow bone. The soft, creamy texture blends effortlessly into the skin, giving you a natural, illuminated look. The highlighter’s long-lasting formula ensures your brows stay lifted and defined throughout the day.
Pros:
- Brush tip applicator for easy precision.
- Blends smoothly for a natural finish.
- Long-lasting formula.
Cons:
- Limited shade range.
- Can feel slightly heavy on the skin.
L’Oréal Paris Brow Stylist Brow Highlighter is perfect for those looking for an affordable, effective brow highlighter with easy application. The brush tip ensures a precise and smooth finish every time.
5. e.l.f. Cosmetics Eyebrow Lifter & Filler
e.l.f. Cosmetics Eyebrow Lifter & Filler is a budget-friendly option that offers both a highlighter and a filler in one dual-ended pencil. The lifter side has a creamy, matte formula that brightens and lifts the brow area, while the filler side defines and shapes the brows. This two-in-one product is perfect for those who want to streamline their makeup routine without sacrificing results.
Pros:
- Dual-ended with lifter and filler functions.
- Affordable and great for beginners.
- Easy to apply and blend.
Cons:
- Limited shade range for the filler side.
- Not as long-lasting as higher-end products.
e.l.f. Eyebrow Lifter & Filler is ideal for those who want an all-in-one product that combines highlighting and brow filling at an affordable price. Its simple application makes it perfect for everyday use.
6. Maybelline New York Brow Precise Highlighter
Maybelline New York Brow Precise Highlighter is a drugstore favorite for those seeking a natural, radiant brow lift. The highlighter features a creamy formula that glides on smoothly and blends effortlessly. It’s designed to define and brighten the brow area, giving you a lifted and polished look. The pencil is available in a range of shades, making it suitable for various skin tones.
Pros:
- Affordable and easy to find.
- Smooth and blendable formula.
- Comes in a range of shades for different skin tones.
Cons:
- May require frequent touch-ups.
- Not as pigmented as some higher-end options.
Maybelline Brow Precise Highlighter is a fantastic budget option for anyone looking to brighten their brow area with minimal effort. Its creamy, blendable formula makes it easy to achieve a natural, lifted look.
Buying Guide: Choosing the Best Eyebrow Highlighter
Formula
The formula is crucial when choosing an eyebrow highlighter. Creamy formulas are easy to blend and provide a more natural look, while powder formulas can offer more staying power. Choose a formula that suits your skin type and desired look.
Finish: Matte or Shimmer
Matte highlighters give a subtle lift to the brows and are perfect for a natural look. Shimmer highlighters add more radiance and are ideal for evening or special occasions. If you want flexibility, choose a product that offers both finishes, like the Anastasia Beverly Hills Highlighting Duo Pencil.
Ease of Application
The applicator type plays a key role in how easy the product is to use. Pencil highlighters offer precision, while brush applicators can help you blend the product seamlessly. Consider your skill level and the kind of control you need.
Shade Range
Ensure the highlighter shade complements your skin tone. A too-light shade can appear harsh, while a too-dark shade may not provide the desired lifting effect. Products like NYX Wonder Pencil offer multiple shades to match different skin tones.
Long-Lasting Formula
Look for highlighters that offer long-lasting wear, especially if you want your brow look to stay intact throughout the day. Products like Benefit High Brow Pencil are known for their staying power.
Conclusion: Improve Your Brows with the Perfect Highlighter
Choosing the right eyebrow highlighter can make a huge difference in your makeup look. Whether you’re going for a subtle lift with Benefit High Brow Pencil or a shimmering finish with Anastasia Beverly Hills Highlighting Duo Pencil, there’s a product for every brow need. The key is to find a formula that works for your skin type, provides the finish you desire, and lasts all day. With our top picks, you’re sure to find the perfect eyebrow highlighter to enhance your look.
Frequently Asked Questions
1. Can I use a regular highlighter for my eyebrows?
While you can use a regular highlighter, eyebrow-specific highlighters are formulated to provide precise application and long-lasting wear in the brow area. These products are designed to lift and define your brows more effectively than general highlighters.
2. How do I apply eyebrow highlighter?
Apply the highlighter directly under the brow bone, following the natural arch of your brow. Blend the product with a brush or your fingertips for a smooth, natural finish. You can also apply a small amount above the brow for added definition.
3. Should I use a matte or shimmer highlighter for my brows?
It depends on your preference. Matte highlighters provide a subtle lift, making them great for daytime looks. Shimmer highlighters add more radiance and are ideal for evening or special occasions.
4. How often should I replace my eyebrow highlighter?
Most makeup products should be replaced every 6-12 months to ensure freshness and prevent bacteria buildup. If your highlighter starts to dry out or change in texture, it’s time to replace it.
5. Can eyebrow highlighters work for all skin tones?
Yes, eyebrow highlighters come in various shades to suit different skin tones. It’s important to choose a shade that complements your skin for a natural look. Many brands offer a range of options to match both lighter and darker complexions.
